Four Compelling Reasons to Use Racial Equity Impact Assessments for Policy Decisions - The Annie E. Casey Foundation

Four Compelling Reasons to Use Racial Equity Impact Assessments for Policy Decisions

Posted August 31, 2016
By the Annie E. Casey Foundation
Blog fourcompellingreasons 2016

Tools for Thought: Using Racial Equi­ty Impact Assess­ments for Effec­tive Pol­i­cy­mak­ing, the third install­ment of the Race for Results case study series, high­lights the use and effec­tive­ness of Racial Equi­ty Impact Assess­ment (REIA) tools, and gives lead­ers and advo­cates a tan­gi­ble mech­a­nism to craft race-con­scious leg­is­la­tion and policies.

REIA tools are instru­ments that use data about race to project the impact of deci­sions on dif­fer­ent pop­u­la­tions. They are designed to help deci­sion-mak­ers under­stand the unique per­spec­tives and needs of var­i­ous pop­u­la­tions in order to find solu­tions that are ben­e­fi­cial for all.

The city of Seat­tle used REIA tools to explore the ques­tion of street­light out­ages in com­mu­ni­ties of col­or, and sub­se­quent­ly redesigned its entire street­light replace­ment sys­tem to bet­ter serve these com­mu­ni­ties and save mon­ey in the process. In Min­neapo­lis, the school board used an REIA tool to deter­mine the poten­tial impact of var­i­ous restruc­tur­ing plans, and learned that some would have unin­tend­ed — yet dire — con­se­quences on Soma­li and Native Amer­i­can neighborhoods.

When deci­sion mak­ers use racial equi­ty impact assess­ments to inform their poli­cies, they take advan­tage of four dis­tinct benefits:

  • An REIA tool helps keep the focus of the deci­sion on data and facts, rather than assump­tions or ingrained beliefs. For exam­ple, a city coun­cil­woman may assume that a com­mu­ni­ty of col­or would sup­port the clos­ing of a dilap­i­dat­ed com­mu­ni­ty cen­ter in exchange for a brand-new build­ing less than a mile away, but in real­i­ty the com­mu­ni­ty may pre­fer ren­o­va­tion rather than a move. 
  • REIA tools pro­vide a sys­tem­at­ic way to engage the opin­ions and voic­es of those who will be affect­ed by the deci­sion, increas­ing under­stand­ing and buy-in for the new pol­i­cy. The coun­cil­woman could use the ques­tions incor­po­rat­ed in an REIA tool to engage in con­ver­sa­tions with com­mu­ni­ty lead­ers or res­i­dents through sur­veys, a meet­ing, or through one-on-one conversations.
  • REIA tools can shed light on the unin­tend­ed con­se­quences of pol­i­cy deci­sions before those deci­sions are made. Through the REIA tool the coun­cil­woman might learn that those with­in the affect­ed com­mu­ni­ty would not have ade­quate trans­porta­tion to the pro­posed com­mu­ni­ty cen­ter site.
  • REIA tools can pro­vide a wider range of options for pol­i­cy choic­es — options that may nev­er have emerged oth­er­wise. The coun­cil­woman now can con­sid­er trans­porta­tion as part of the deci­sion and include ren­o­vat­ing the exist­ing site, build­ing a new cen­ter clos­er to the com­mu­ni­ty, incor­po­rat­ing a trans­porta­tion plan or oth­er cre­ative solutions.

In many cas­es, pre­vent­ing inequity is more cost effec­tive than repair­ing an inequitable sys­tem. Qual­i­ty ear­ly learn­ing for a low-income child is much more cost effec­tive than pro­vid­ing reme­di­a­tion ser­vices once that child drops out of high school.

But, per­haps, more impor­tant­ly, using an REIA tool to inform pol­i­cy deci­sions means that pol­i­cy­mak­ers and gov­ern­ment employ­ees are embrac­ing a com­mon­ly held val­ue of racial equi­ty. When that val­ue is man­i­fest, qual­i­ty of life improves for everyone.

Read or down­load Tools for Thought

This post is related to: